Tuesday, April 01, 2008

which is your club?


Its 3:30AM in the morning.. I just completed writing this blog entry & really tired.. Feeling a lot of relief once i completed this.. Its been 2 weeks since I started writing this one & wanted to make it perfect because this is what I wanted to shout out at this world for s long.. so read on...


I was watching the sports channel the other day when I saw a huge riot in a football stadium. I didn't understand what was the reason for the commotion but watched the policemen beat up the angry mob. People were throwing stones, empty bottles & attacking the policemen at first. The second scene showed some stalls being burnt & lot of fire in the stadium created by the crowd. The police didn't stand back either, they returned with water canons on the angry mob. The pretty newsreader lady at the end of the video explained that this was the riot which resulted at the end of a football somewhere in the west. The feature which followed explained how this was a common scene after each football match. Well, not used to seeing such happenings in our country, I decided to do some "googl-ing" and read about the football riots on the net. What I saw was really shocking, football fans burning, attacking & destroying property & seriously injuring supporters of their rival teams.


The news about the riot in Japan in the year 2005 which resulted in the death of 300, was the most nastiest incident in football history. All these news made me curious on finding out more about these “clubs”. I decided to research on the two biggest club football rivals itself, Manchester United & Liverpool. In spite of the numerous similarities between the clubs they have been arch rivals. Both the clubs are based out of two different places in England. But both teams have players from all over the world playing for it ( nothing to do with patriotism). Both have its team colors, team flags, team songs & team jerseys. Both have their respective heroes, who are considered a level above the normal human, which can be explained by the money they make every hour even when they are not playing. Even after going reading all this, I still didn't understand one basic thing... Y are the people killing each other just because they like a particular football team??? Y do the people of these rival groups look at each other with hatred & keep away from the other??? Y is the only interaction between the two clubs only violence??? It just didn't make sense !!! The people are from the same part of the country, they speak the same language, they are from same ethnicity, neither of them did anything wrong for which they should be punished. Then why???


I tried thinking about it in a different perspective. For doing that, we have to go a level higher. No, not to a higher sport, but to a higher level of grouping. Lets say region wise.. It was in the late 1940s that two similar “groups” were formed in the Asian sub-continent. These groups had much bigger members which makes us difficult to actually call them as clubs, but when we compare them with the previous analogy, they are quite similar to the English clubs. These two “groups” again formed two different areas of the Asian sub-continent. Though it was a single mass of land at first, formation of the “groups”/”clubs” forced it to be divided as separate regions having a common border. The two groups again had their respective colors, their flags and even the distinct song. But again members of both groups spoke the same languages, were from the same ethnicity, believed in similar religions even. But still, from its moment of creation till this day, it has only been hatred between the two groups. Even these two groups had their respective heroes, though heroes changed over time, never did the groups unite. The only difference between the football clubs & these groups is the fact that, in this case the leaders itself was the reason for the creation of these two groups. People who used to stand as one, was divided by barb wires & fences just because of the ego & difference of a few men. Yes, again the opinion of these few men were valued more than the others, hence their decision to form groups & separate people was put into practice. I am not talking about any fairy tale in any far off land, but the plight of two countries India & Pakistan after the separation in 1947. The stubbornness & ego of a few men resulting in decades of bloodshed. Do we ever stand up & ask each other why we fight. What is that we hate in our so much that we are even willing to die but wont let our neighbor set foot in our land? How is that we actually differ? Don't we share almost the similar gene pool even? On any given day can we actually spot the difference between an Indian & our neighbor.. Nobody knows... But yet we don't get up... we don't get up & try to see over the walls we have created around us...


But still I don't want to stop here.. Lets go 1 more level up.. In this level the “groups”/”clubs” are not divided by barb wires or fences. The members of these groups cannot be again distinguished based on their ethnicity, color of their skin nor the languages they speak. The members of these clubs were both & brought up in the same land. They cultivate the same soil, eat the same food, speak similar languages but yet they seem to treat the other differently. The members of these groups often fight & the clashes always lead to bloodshed & death. Every year millions of people die due to clashes between these rival “clubs”. The members are not isolated to a particular region or country, but in fact they are spread equally in the world. Though members of different clubs interact, it is often bound by limits. Relationships & marriage between members of different clubs are a big taboo & again leads to bloodshed. These clubs again have its own colors, its own songs, its own “constitution” or rule book which assigns the rights & duties of its members. It has its own heroes as well, both human & supernatural. While the supernatural remain only in the books & pictures, the human form often competes with its rivals to prove superiority. These “clubs” or “groups” had been created & followed for one reason alone, to separate, to distinguish & differentiate people on the basis of their beliefs.


Man always tried to explain the various phenomena which happened around him. For doing so he used either the help of science or help of the supernatural. Anything which man couldn't explain with science ended up as being the work of the supernatural. As years passed by and man evolved, many of the things which were once called supernatural became known as science. The Sun, Moon, rain, lightning were earlier considered as work of the supernatural, but as time passed by, man identified these as forces of nature & had explanation for each of these. But yet there were quiet a few which man was yet to discover.. He tried explaining these phenomena as work of the supernatural & as always different people explained these phenomena differently. This lead to different beliefs among the same human kind & finally man's ignorance slowly created religion... Man's creative mind helped him create characters which had superhuman strength & abilities. These heroes were the main characters in the “constitution” or rule books each religion had. Each hero had a special ability, if one could cure diseases, other could eradicate hunger. When one created the world, other destroyed the world. When one created wealth other blessed man with wisdom. In this way for each & every need man had a hero.. ( no I am not talking about the Justice League on Cartoon Network).


But here we stand in the 22nd century, completely clueless on why we are fighting. We are fighting each other simply based on religious beliefs, the same beliefs which was created by man himself. As soon as a child is born the name of a religion is stamped on it & he bears it for the rest of his life. The human no more has a choice as to select his belief but is forced to believe what his forefathers believed. Though religious “groups” were formed based on people who think alike, now it is more of people who are bound & forced to think in a particular way. When will we stand up & realize that the wall we have around is, was created by us alone??? When will we realize that the people whom we hurt & kill, are no different from us.. What are we doing to each other.. When will we stand up & look above the wall...

8 comments:

Tejas said...

great almagamation of perspectives! good work AJ ....

Amal said...

Achilles,
Lost are the reasons of the origin of religion and its heros. If we look deeper in to the soul of the "Groups" they were meant to keep people united as one, spirit of the healthy competition meant to improve each and every one, quest into the unknown meant to open the doors of knowledge...
But all the self-centered intelligence (?) has blinded us from the facts, or rather we purposefully forget them?
A good leap forward is to first understand, we have our eyes closed (rather blind?). See Malayalam movie Guru...

Raj said...

I guess I have the answer for you

There are 5 different types of people in the world
1) Driven by faith & Practical Experience.
2) Driven by Dissatisfaction & Practical Experience.
3) Driven by Scare of the society & Practical Experience.
4) Driven by Instincts & Practical Experience.
5) Driven by Common Sense & Practical Experience.
I guess you can find examples for each category for a better understanding.
The more they stick to their category, the more powerful they become, and the more they hate a similar group of the same category.

But the most powerful, most popular and the most dangerous is the first one - FAITH

Why faith is powerful?
Faith in a club, country, or religion, or college, or company always brings the best in you, because you believe in it, like you believe in yourself.

Why faith is dangerous?
Faith in a club, country, or religion, or college, or company always creates an insecure feeling, which is natural because
at times common sense or society questions your faith, and the distrust and confusion in you explodes and damages the surroundings.
This happens only if your faith doesn’t have enough support, recognition and practical evidences. To avoid such unstable situations, it requires to keep this faith stable.
And to be stable it requires to be fuelled continuously. Anything which comes against gets damaged just to sustain the faith.

On a positive note
The difference between humans and animals is that animals adapt with the surroundings while humans change the surroundings to adapt. But the limit of adaptation is different for different people due to many reasons. This diversity is the fuel which drives the progress of humanity. Those who can’t sustain the change would try to stop it, and this is what causes the rivalry which you have described with different analogies. The more you resist these natural changes, the more you get damaged and some times fatal 


Rajeev
A man not busy being born is busy dying 

neo said...

Amazing.
A very good post, one that should be heard far n wide, one to be given a thought about.

The idea of moving zeitgeist should be realised, that the old belief systems should be replaced by one that runs with the current understanding of our world. MANY of these religious people - generally the orthodox, d fundamentalists, the extremists are still stuck in those centuries that 've actually passed by....

@Amal,
'groups' or the 'Clubs' that 'Achilles' has tried to explain here are ones with in-group unity and out-group hostility. And thats the case with our world. Maybe it is time we did rise above small self's and see what we are doing..

Amal said...

@Raj,
Can we really categorize people just like that? I think its like telling a child there is no number between 1 and 2. We grow up and find a lot more numbers between them, and numbers beyond definition. Simply put, groups are like numbers here and people can be anywhere between them as well, and hence I believe the number of Categories tends to infinite...

@Suraj,
While some groups where born to fight for their cause, some of them are really born just to keep people united by probably faith, or by their geographic region or language. Its hard to penetrate the minds of the hostile groups and make them understand the basic message: "Respect each other as an individual; the groups should better people than deter us" I believe in the natural selection - survival of the fittest - wherein the hostile groups will fight, no matter what the visionaries of peace say, and they fight for and against and will eventually perish. But its a very slow process and it will take a lot of people who don't belong to any of the groups as well. Again, a rotten leaf just fertilizes the tree itself.

By the way its nice to find like-minded people but we are invisibly forming another "Group" which seeks peace among the existing groups. Well, just a thought!

Raj said...

@Amal
The categorization of people is based on the focal point of discussion. It’s not necessarily a finite set. But its a general classification which covers the major chunk may be few more could be added if the sitiuation asks for

You are right its exactly like telling a child there is no number between 1 and 2. But even now if you are to teach a child you would say the same :) It's because the situation doesn't demand more and at times more could be disastrous.

Same way the issue under discussion just needed a broad classification to describe the reasons.

Its accepted that there are so variety of people which could fall between these categories
say like those driven by
10% faith,10% dissatisfaction
10% combination of many others. Such detail level classification sets could vary from 1 to the total population count. But does that help in any ways to make a big difference in the current explanation

Achilles said...

@Amal/Suraj,
Its hard to penetrate the minds of the hostile groups and make them understand the basic message: "Respect each other as an individual; the groups should better people than deter us" I believe in the natural selection - survival of the fittest - wherein the hostile groups will fight, no matter what the visionaries of peace say, and they fight for and against and will eventually perish.

Well I completely disagree with the point expressed before. We all learnt in class 6 that all matter is based out of molecules & later in class 8th or 9nth we discovered molecules are not the smallest particle , but molecules are in turn made up of atoms. Further in our higher studies we learnt atoms can be again broken down... Didnt understand what I am trying to say? Nations, regions, religious institutions are all made up of the same building block.. Human beings, like u & me. Sitting in the comfort of our home we can look out & say let the groups battle out against each other & let the fittest win, but these groups who fight & kill are people like us.

A friend of mine recently told me that the biggest turning point in our life is beyond our control, it is our birth. The kind of family & place we are born into determines how we will grow up to be. We have no idea how we might have turned into if we had born into a family suffering from communal clashes. What if we were born in a family in Israel or Palestine. The situation would be much different, we would have been part of the group which we are now watching fight on tv.

My point is that each group is made of individuals & only if each individual change the group can change. Obviously when a person tries to change the natural tendency of the people around him, is to oppose. But as more & more people spread the word, stand up & realize what they are doing is wrong, the group changes.

Its is individuals which make a group & define a group.

Athira said...

it is indeed ridiculous that people need to fight over their beliefs. So what if the person sitting next to you believes in a different principle or belongs to a different group? U and your sibling are not entirely identical in your beliefs. Nor are you and your parents. So would you wish to argue / fight with them too?

All groups start with the good intention of uniting the people believing in it as one. But they soon give way to animosities among people belonging to different groups. Soon your very purpose of being in a group shifts from the "safeguarding of its interests" to "resisting anything antithetic to its interests". Seen the papers today? Some Hindu outfit has slammed a case against Mallika Sherawat, just coz she dressed as she would do in movies / functions - in a glam attire. God knows why this outfit came into existence. But now their propaganda is to pull up people not having any remote connection to themselves and practise moral policing. A lot of unnecessary dispute start from these trivial issues.

Individual change is alas, the only effective solution to these issues. But that is only a far-fetched dream.